Welcome Guest!

Brazilian Court to Ban ELFC Sales?

online TreeFittyactivity 1521 Days Agoaffiliates 1392 Viewsforums 3 Comments
Kotaku has posted an interesting article related to the Episodes from Liberty City Soundtrack.

The song in question...


"Today, a Civil Court in Barueri (São Paulo) has targeted Rockstar Games and Synergex Brazil, claiming improper use of the song that made you all dance through Liberty City. "Conga Kid" is said to be an unauthorized sample of "Bota o Dedinho pro Alto", by Brazilian composer Hamilton Lourenço da Silva, father of MC Miltinho (an eight-year-old boy we can see here.)

The injunction says that Rockstar and Synergex "are restricted from trading and distributing the expansion Episodes From Liberty City", and that the game must be collected from stores – not only in Brazil, but worldwide. The decision, apparently, also applies to digital versions of the game. There is a fine of R$ 5,000 (US$ 3,000) for each day the Grand Theft Auto expansion pack continues to be sold.

Rockstar has presented documents authorizing the use of the music, but the signatures were not those of the authors of the lawsuit. So we have copyright issues and an international dispute involving the Brazilian composer, Rockstar Games and the German label Man Recordings, responsible for the music included in The Ballad of Tony Gay."

There is a note at the bottom as an update response from Rockstar themselves:
"A Rockstar spokesperson responded to our inquiry, telling us that the company has not received any notice from the court about this matter and are looking into the news reports from Brazil."

Who will win? Is it even true? We'll find out eventually... In the meantime hang on tight to your copy of Episodes from Liberty City!
Comments
online demonactivity 1521 Days Ago
HTF can a Brazilian court forbid the sale of EFLC worldwide? The rest of the world is outside of their jurisdiction. The court can go and suck a stick of bamboo. dry.gif
online Massacreactivity 1521 Days Ago
Oh, sweet.

*Goes to Brazil to sell black market copies of EFLC*
online TreeFittyactivity 1521 Days Ago
(demon)
HTF can a Brazilian court forbid the sale of EFLC worldwide? The rest of the world is outside of their jurisdiction. The court can go and suck a stick of bamboo. dry.gif


It's a bit of a sticky situation. If they are found guilty of infringing a copyright there, then the case can ripple out to other countries where copyrights are upheld. "If it's illegal here, it's illegal everywhere" that type of thing.

Similar example: There's been court cases in one part of the US that overthrow national issues.
Comment On This News Article

Log In to post a comment on this news article.