Help - Search - Members - Calendar
Full Version: Good or Bad?
iGrandTheftAuto.com Forums > Red Dead Series > Red Dead Redemption
Indy
Just wondering how everyone is playing this game and what the most evil or heroic things you've accomplished are?
I've started off completely honourable and I reckon I'll stay this way too. Though I did accidentally shoot two lawmen who were chasing a bandit once, got me in a bit of trouble but I managed to escape.
bOnEs
i'm trying to play this game as a do-gooder... but, some random encounters are hard to tell which side is the good side and i've killed lawmen and farmers by accident... but, i try to do the honorable thing... i'll ignore pleas from citizens about getting their horse or money back because, sometimes i just don't feel like intervening every time i enter a town...

so, i guess i am playing this game good but, teetering near the neutral line a bit...
coreyko_2003
I try to play the good guy but sometimes I like to be a fuck and do dishonorable things........then again I'll do something dishonorable but I'll make it up by doing something.....nice, like help out some unfortunate that got robbed or kidnapped.
PabloHoneyOle
I'm playing good for the most part. I am however notorious for killing women.
Hardcore Ottoman
I need to see what being bad does. Funny how everyone here is not bad, per se.
PabloHoneyOle
I think my next playthrough will be bad. Although, how bad can you really be? You'll still have to progress through the storyline and do "good" things. You're only opportunities to be "bad" are during side missions or just killing everyone that's not essential to the storyline and killing the law that will continuously come after you.
Assassin
Good guy ftw, well seen as though you can't really be a bad guy that much, apart from killing Randoms like stoic said. So I think it's better to let Marston wander down the honerable path.
ViceMan
As John I was good, but as Jack i've been ignoring many peoples pleas for help.
Chicago51
I'm letting the man lead the honorable life for now, to make up for his past misdeeds. Not far into the story tho. So if anything happens to poor Mrs. Marston or Junior.....God help them all........
bOnEs
i started my evil file a few days ago and, it just doesn't feel right... i'll pistol execute some folk at macfarlane's ranch, kill enough to loose the wanted level, then proceed to do a mission for bonnie and have her tell me how i am a good person laugh.gif... and finishing missions so far is giving me positive honor, which is counterproductive to all the killing i've been doing...
DiO
QUOTE (bOnEs @ Jun 2 2010, 12:43 PM) *
i started my evil file a few days ago and, it just doesn't feel right... i'll pistol execute some folk at macfarlane's ranch, kill enough to loose the wanted level, then proceed to do a mission for bonnie and have her tell me how i am a good person laugh.gif... and finishing missions so far is giving me positive honor, which is counterproductive to all the killing i've been doing...



Which is pretty much why I went good. I got a file saved before the ending. Im gonna do lots of killing and beat it again and I hope I get that dark horse.
DuPz0r
QUOTE (DiO @ Jun 2 2010, 06:48 PM) *
QUOTE (bOnEs @ Jun 2 2010, 12:43 PM) *
i started my evil file a few days ago and, it just doesn't feel right... i'll pistol execute some folk at macfarlane's ranch, kill enough to loose the wanted level, then proceed to do a mission for bonnie and have her tell me how i am a good person laugh.gif... and finishing missions so far is giving me positive honor, which is counterproductive to all the killing i've been doing...



Which is pretty much why I went good. I got a file saved before the ending. Im gonna do lots of killing and beat it again and I hope I get that dark horse.


I might do the same. I couldn't help but be good first time round, it just sets you up in the narrative to be a good person so...

DiO
QUOTE (DuPz0r @ Jun 2 2010, 02:34 PM) *
QUOTE (DiO @ Jun 2 2010, 06:48 PM) *
QUOTE (bOnEs @ Jun 2 2010, 12:43 PM) *
i started my evil file a few days ago and, it just doesn't feel right... i'll pistol execute some folk at macfarlane's ranch, kill enough to loose the wanted level, then proceed to do a mission for bonnie and have her tell me how i am a good person laugh.gif... and finishing missions so far is giving me positive honor, which is counterproductive to all the killing i've been doing...



Which is pretty much why I went good. I got a file saved before the ending. Im gonna do lots of killing and beat it again and I hope I get that dark horse.


I might do the same. I couldn't help but be good first time round, it just sets you up in the narrative to be a good person so...

Definitely R*'s indention. Though you can wear the bandanna and do whatever you want without it affecting your honour.
Marney1
QUOTE (bOnEs @ May 24 2010, 09:52 PM) *
i'm trying to play this game as a do-gooder... but, some random encounters are hard to tell which side is the good side and i've killed lawmen and farmers by accident... but, i try to do the honorable thing... i'll ignore pleas from citizens about getting their horse or money back because, sometimes i just don't feel like intervening every time i enter a town...

so, i guess i am playing this game good but, teetering near the neutral line a bit...

Exactly that ^
Hardcore Ottoman
Thieves Landing has bandannas. Not sure when they become available though. Wear 'em during missions if you want to stay morally bad.
This is a "lo-fi" version of our main content. To view the full version with more information, formatting and images, please click here.
Invision Power Board © 2001-2014 Invision Power Services, Inc.