Dwayne is upset because he did everything and gave everything to his girlfriend when he was in prison, and now she's banging the guy who fingered Dwayne and got him sent down in the first place. Niko offers to ask them for the money back, and Dwayne agrees.
Kill Cherise or Let Her Live?
Grab a vehicle and head down to the Arcade in China Town. Niko will confront the couple when you get there. Jayvon will run away like a sissy and you'll be given the choice whether you want to kill his girl or not.
CHOICE 1: Kill Cherise
If you kill Cherise, she will not appear further in the game as a random pedestrian.
CHOICE 2: Let Her Live
If you let Cherise live, you can meet her later on in the game and do a mission for her.
The Choice Is Made
Decide what you want to do with Cherise quickly, then jump on the bike and chase after Jayvon. If he escapes, you'll fail the mission. Drive-by him, and once he's dead, get his money.
Next, you'll need to head to Cluckin' Bell and meet Dwayne. Follow your GPS and make your way there. Head inside and speak to Dwayne. You'll give him the cash and Niko will explain what happened to Cherise (depending on your decision).
- Make sure you've got some form of drive-by weapon before chasing after Jayvon. An Uzi will take him out very easily, but you might want to stock up on ammo first.